Heretic (2024) Review: Scare Level & Mormon Reaction

When you first hear that a horror film centers on two Mormon missionaries knocking on a stranger’s door, you might brace for cheap shocks. Instead, Heretic (2024) serves up something trickier: a psychological battle where faith, logic, and fear collide.

Release Year: 2024 ·
Director: Scott Beck and Bryan Woods ·
Genre: Psychological horror ·
Lead Actor: Hugh Grant ·
Studio: A24

Seven key facts at a glance:

How scary is the film Heretic?

One persistent question from potential viewers: does Heretic deliver real scares or fake-out jump moments? Critics broadly agree it leans on psychological dread rather than cheap shocks. Rotten Tomatoes (critic aggregation site) describes it as preaching “the gospel of cerebral chills over cheap shocks.” A review on the Possessed by Horror (YouTube channel) called it “more of a psychological movie than a particularly scary one.”

Does Heretic rely on jump scares or psychological dread?

• The tension builds through dialogue and intellectual manipulation, not sudden noises (Inverse (editorial publication)).
• We Live Entertainment (film review site) frames it as a “psychological horror film rooted in an examination of religion.”
• The film is rated R for “some bloody violence” but is not gore-heavy (Rotten Tomatoes).

How does the horror compare to other A24 horror films?

Three notable comparisons:

• vs. The Witch: Both use period dialogue? Heretic is contemporary, relying on theological debate.
• vs. Hereditary: Heretic is less visceral; the horror is intellectual rather than familial trauma.
• vs. Midsommar: Both explore belief systems, but Heretic is contained in a single house whereas Midsommar is expansive.

Inverse dubbed it “Saw for Reddit atheism” — a smart, talky horror that rewards close attention.

What age recommendation is appropriate for Heretic?

The film carries an R rating from the MPAA for “some bloody violence.” Most critics suggest 16+ due to thematic intensity and disturbing sequences. It is not recommended for younger teens or those sensitive to religious coercion.

What was the point of the film Heretic?

At its simplest, Heretic is a probing critique of organized religion wrapped in a thriller. The plot: two young Mormon missionaries, Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East), knock on the door of Mr. Reed (Hugh Grant). What begins as a polite conversation turns into a psychological trap designed to test and dismantle their faith (Wikipedia (reference source)).

What themes does Heretic explore?

• Faith versus skepticism: Mr. Reed uses logic and evidence to challenge belief (Derek Ex Machina (film review blog)).
• Indoctrination and doubt: the film asks why people believe what they were taught as children.
• Power and control: Reed’s game is about who holds authority over truth.

How does the film critique organized religion?

The Guardian (UK newspaper) calls Grant’s performance “suave, dapper and evil,” and notes the film “preaches the gospel of cerebral chills over cheap shocks.” The critique is not anti-faith per se but targets dogmatic thinking and the vulnerability of true believers.

What is the significance of the title ‘Heretic’?

The title works on two levels: the character Reed is a heretic (one who challenges established beliefs), and the missionaries themselves become heretics within the story when their faith is tested. A24 (indie film studio) positions Heretic as “religious horror” on its official page (A24 (official distributor website)).

Was Heretic a good film?

Critical reception is split along a familiar fault line: is a smart, messy film better than a polished but forgettable one? Here’s how the major reviews break down.

What do critics say about Heretic?

• Rotten Tomatoes critical consensus: “Hugh Grant has infectious fun playing against type in Heretic, a religious horror that preaches the gospel of cerebral chills over cheap shocks.” (Rotten Tomatoes)
• The Guardian: “Gruesome and bizarre and preposterous, the third aspect made palatable by Grant’s dapper performance of evil.” (The Guardian)
• Inverse: “[Nothing on its mind] simultaneously silly and pulse-pounding.” (Inverse)

What do audience reviews indicate?

On IMDb (user review site), one top review reads: “Heretic is as unpredictable as it is messy. While the film keeps you on edge for most of its runtime, the plot begins to fizzle out in the final act.” Audience scores are more mixed than critic scores, with many praising Grant and the first two acts but criticizing the resolution.

How does Heretic compare to other 2024 horror films?

In a year that gave us Longlegs, Immaculate, and The First Omen, Heretic stands apart by being the only one built almost entirely around dialogue. It lacks the visual terror of Longlegs and the religious spectacle of Immaculate, but it wins on originality of premise.

The pattern across reviews: Heretic is a must-watch for fans of intellectual horror but will frustrate viewers seeking a tidy, conventional scare.

What do Mormons think about the movie Heretic?

Because the film features two LDS missionaries as protagonists, the Mormon perspective is a natural point of curiosity. Wikipedia (reference source) confirms the plot revolves around missionaries from The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

How does Heretic portray Mormon missionaries?

• The missionaries are portrayed as young, earnest, and somewhat naive—believers whose faith is tested harshly.
• They wear traditional missionary attire and use LDS-specific language (e.g., “We have a message for you”).
• The film does not mock their beliefs but uses them as a foil for Reed’s atheistic arguments.

What has been the reaction from LDS communities?

On Reddit (r/A24 forum), discussions are active. Some LDS viewers have expressed discomfort at seeing their faith used as a plot device, while others appreciate the respectful treatment of the missionaries. As of now, no official statement from the LDS church has been released.

Is the film considered offensive to Mormons?

The consensus among commenters is that Heretic is not overtly offensive but may be unsettling because it depicts a scenario real missionaries could face: a charismatic stranger challenging their beliefs. The film does not depict the church as malevolent; rather, it questions the strength of any faith when put under pressure.

Is Heretic based off a true story?

A common question: could something like this happen? The answer, according to all available evidence, is no.

What real events inspired Heretic?

• Wikipedia (reference source) lists the film as entirely fictional, no “based on a true story” tag.
• No credible news reports link the plot to an actual event.
• The writers/directors, Scott Beck and Bryan Woods, have not claimed a real-life inspiration in interviews.

Are the characters based on real people?

Hugh Grant’s Mr. Reed is a composite archetype of the intellectual predator, not a specific real individual. The missionaries represent general LDS missionary experience, not any particular person.

What is the filmmakers’ statement on inspiration?

In press notes, Beck and Woods said they wanted to explore “the architecture of belief” (paraphrased from A24 (official page)). There is no mention of a true story.

Comparison: Heretic vs. Other A24 Horror Films

Three key dimensions separate Heretic from earlier A24 horror hits.

Heretic Technical Specifications

Six specs that define the film’s release profile.

Pros and Cons of Heretic

Confirmed and Unclear Aspects

What Critics Are Saying

Hugh Grant has infectious fun playing against type in Heretic, a religious horror that preaches the gospel of cerebral chills over cheap shocks.

— Rotten Tomatoes (critic aggregation)

Heretic is gruesome and bizarre and preposterous, the third aspect made palatable by Grant’s dapper performance of evil.

— The Guardian (UK newspaper)

Heretic is as unpredictable as it is messy. While the film keeps you on edge for most of its runtime, the plot begins to fizzle out in the final act.

— IMDb user review (audience perspective)

For horror fans seeking intellectual dread, Heretic delivers; for those wanting a tidy resolution, the third act may frustrate. The implication: this is a film that rewards discussion more than passive viewing, and that may be exactly what makes it linger.

For a deeper look at the cast and plot, check out our Heretic film cast and plot overview.

Frequently asked questions

Related reading

• Jumanji: Welcome to the Jungle: Cast, Plot, Streaming & Jumanji 4
• In the Mood for Love: Plot, Ending & Why It’s a Masterpiece